IDX

Listed by Joel Schemmel · Courtesy of PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY · Agent MLS ID# MFR281504356 · Deemed reliable but not guaranteed. · Data last updated: Feb 12, 2025 · 5:21 PM

4311 BAY SHORE RD

$6,600,000

4Bedrooms
6Bathrooms
5,033Sq Ft
1925Year Built
4Garage
36Days on Market
0.74 acLot Size

Nestled on nearly three-quarters of an acre, this meticulously updated 1925 Mediterranean Revival residence offers breathtaking, panoramic views of Sarasota Bay, encompassing the downtown skyline, Ringling Bridge and the northern tip of Longboat Key. While preserving its historic charm and original elegance, the home seamlessly integrates modern upgrades designed for both gracious living and entertaining. Upon entering through the gated entry, visitors are greeted by a serene garden with a koi pond and a spacious circular driveway featuring a central fountain, providing ample parking. The gated courtyard leads to a welcoming foyer, which serves as a gateway to the home’s expansive living spaces. To one side lies the formal living room, adorned with a coffered ceiling and an ornate fireplace, while the opposite side reveals a newly renovated kitchen, thoughtfully designed with a Sub-Zero refrigerator, AGA induction range, dolomite countertops, galley sinks and a cozy breakfast area. The formal dining room is perfect for hosting friends and family, offering bay views, a hand-painted recessed ceiling, a marble fireplace and custom built-ins for storage, display and serving. Adjacent to the dining room, the office/den provides tranquil spaces with views of the pool and bay. The great room, with its soaring ceilings, stately fireplace and 10-foot arched doors creates a stunning venue for entertaining, flowing effortlessly onto a spacious covered terrace perfect for sunset views. The second floor boasts three generously sized en-suite bedrooms, each with access to private terraces that showcase captivating vistas. The primary suite, completely reimagined in 2021, epitomizes luxury and relaxation with a custom-trimmed ceiling, a large window for endless Gulf of Mexico views, two French doors leading to an expansive terrace and a custom-organized walk-in closet. The primary bathroom is a retreat with an oversized walk-in shower, floating vanity, a free-standing soaking tub and stunning details and finishes throughout. Designed by renowned landscape architect Michael Gilkey, the grounds have been transformed into distinct outdoor "rooms," featuring a bocce court, expansive patios and a beautifully tiled, heated pool. A charming guesthouse, located adjacent to one of the two two-car garages, includes two rooms, two bathrooms and a kitchenette. With a pocket door, the space can be configured as two separate en-suite bedrooms for ultimate flexibility. Additional enhancements include updated HVAC systems, air conditioning for the garages, upgraded electrical systems, LED and Lutron lighting and hurricane-impact windows and doors. Conveniently located in Indian Beach and Sapphire Shores, this residence is close to downtown Sarasota, SRQ Airport and numerous dining and shopping options. Known as Casa Arula, this remarkable property harmoniously blends historical significance with modern sophistication, creating a truly exceptional place to call home.

What's special

PoolWaterfront4-Car Garage

Facts & Features

MLS ID#
MFRA4633705
PRICE
$6,600,000
STATUS
Active
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
6
FULL BATHS
5
HALF BATHS
1
SQUARE FOOTAGE
5,033 sqft
ACRES
0.74
YEAR BUILT
1925
TYPE
Single Family Residence
SUB-TYPE
N/A
STYLE
Custom, Mediterranean, Historic

Community Information

ADDRESS
4311 BAY SHORE RD
SUBDIVISION
Indian Beach/Sapphire Shores
CITY
Sarasota
COUNTY
Sarasota
STATE
FL
ZIP CODE
34234
SENIOR COMMUNITY
No

Amenities

AMENITIES
N/A
PARKING
N/A
VIEW
No
WATERFRONT
Yes
POOL
Yes

Interior

INTERIOR FEATURES
Ceiling Fans(s), Eat-in Kitchen, High Ceilings, Stone Counters, Crown Molding, Window Treatments, Walk-In Closet(s), Wet Bar, Built-in Features, Central Vaccum, Thermostat, PrimaryBedroom Upstairs, Coffered Ceiling(s)
HEATING
Central, Electric
COOLING
Central Air, Humidity Control, Zoned, Mini-Split Unit(s)
FLOORING
Ceramic Tile, Marble, Wood, Tile, Travertine
FIREPLACE
Wood Burning, Living Room, Family Room, Gas, Other
STORIES
2
APPLIANCES
Dishwasher, Disposal, Microwave, Range, Electric Water Heater, Refrigerator, Dryer, Washer, Freezer, Exhaust Fan, Range Hood, Bar Fridge, Ice Maker, Water Softener

Exterior

EXTERIOR FEATURES
Lighting, French Doors, Irrigation System, Rain Gutters, Balcony, Private Mailbox, Garden
CONSTRUCTION
Block, Stucco, Wood Frame, Cement Siding
FOUNDATION
Block
ROOF
Membrane, Tile
FENCING
Fenced, Other
LOT DESCRIPTION
Paved, Near Public Transit, Historic District, Near Golf Course, Near Marina

School Information

ELEMENTARY
Emma East Booker Elementary
MIDDLE
Booker Middle
HIGH
Booker High

Additional Information

DATE LISTED
January 7, 2025
DAYS ON MARKET
36
ZONING
RSFE
DIRECTION FACES
Northeast
NEW CONSTRUCTION
No
SPECIAL CONDITIONS
None

36 days on market

Listing updated: Feb 12, 2025 · 5:21 PM

Listed by: Joel Schemmel · 941-587-4894 — PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

Source: Stellar MLS (My Florida Regional MLS) · MLS ID# MFRA4633705

MLS/IDX data last updated: September 20, 2026 2:00 PM . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by the broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information

IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website.

LOCATION

Similar Properties

4819 HIGEL AVE — home for sale

$5,392,000

4819 higel ave

4Beds
6Baths
MFRA4620571MLS ID
4,220SqFt

BRIGHT REALTY

300 GARDEN LN — home for sale

$2,590,000

300 garden ln

4Beds
4Baths
MFRA4662830MLS ID
3,256SqFt

WILLIAM RAVEIS REAL ESTATE

10577 ECLIPSE ST — home for sale

$693,459

10577 eclipse st

3Beds
3Baths
MFRA4693195MLS ID
2,085SqFt

TAYLOR MORRISON RLTY OF FLA

hussein

Discover your perfect living spot in Florida. Buy, sell and rent with an agent you can trust.

Stellar MLS

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of September 20, 2026 2:00 PM. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.